Education: Home & Otherwise

When I started the education category for this blog so many years ago, I had no idea where our educational journey would take us. At that point in time, it was meant to encompass homeschooling and seminary; since then, it has taken on Craig as a high school teacher and various daughters in public school preschool programs and speech services. And now this fall we will embark upon a new chapter in our educational journey: our two oldest daughters will be going to a Christian school.

It is not a decision we flippantly made. It has been an option on the table for us for several years, though it never seemed like the right time then. While the final decision came upon us rather quickly, it has the Lord’s hand on it and we are grateful for His leading and provision to make it happen.

The obvious question we’re being asked is “Why?” Why now? It’s a valid question, and I’m not entirely sure a blog post can do the answer justice, though I will take a stab at it here.

Reason #1: We believe it is time. While we have no regrets about our homeschooling decisions thus far with all of the girls, we believe our oldest two are at a place where their education will be enhanced by the school they will be attending in the fall. I’ve come to realize more and more that the older the girls get, the less I can do with each one of them. The two oldest are having to do a lot of things on their own and I’m not sorry that they’ve learned this valuable skill of independent learning. However, I do see how they thrive from cooperative learning experiences and the exchange of ideas they get from other kids. I think their training in independent learning will only be an asset to them as they go into more of a group-driven learning environment.

Reason #2: I believe I am a really good homeschooling teacher…to about two kids. This is not at all to say that my younger two haven’t learned anything in the past couple of years, but when I had to choose whether to read aloud the older level books or the younger ones, I always defaulted to the older ones. My younger two have been champs at sitting in on all the upper level Sonlight read-alouds we do (and ironically, my 8yo auditory learner seems to have better comprehension skills of some of these readers than my older girls do!), but I’ve been sad that they’ve missed out on many great books from the earlier Sonlight levels. I’m going to make up for that next year. The two oldest girls were assessed in several areas last week by the school and I was relieved to hear very positive results there in terms of high school reading levels and on-target math. They have a great foundation for going into this situation. It is now time I turn more focused attention to the two younger learners in our home.

Reason #3: Believe it or not, part of our rationale here is relationship-driven. My oldest daughter and I can tend to butt heads. I’ll be honest by saying that when I’ve heard parents use that as an excuse to not homeschool, I’ve rolled my eyes internally before and thought, “All the more reason TO homeschool.” I know that sin issues between us will not disappear simply because she’s at school each day, but I am hoping this new situation will help diffuse some hostility that can be a factor in our relating to one another.

Simply put, I am not willing to sacrifice my relationship with my daughter on the altar of home education. I would much rather focus on her as a person and her character and who she is in Christ than argue with her over how much time it’s taking her to do her math. And, as much as I don’t want to admit this, I will: I know that my persona as the homeschool mom who has her act together can be an idol for me. Making the decision to put two kids in school was a wrenching one in that regard. I had to wrestle with all of the “what am I going to say to _________” or “how is this going to look to ____________,” and that was hard.

I was talking to a new-to-us friend the other day who was homeschooled all her years. In her own words, she had a fairly rebellious ending to her time at home. By grace alone, she has not forsaken God and is a very sweet and amazing young gal now. To talk with her you would never guess she had such a shaky entry into adulthood. I mentioned to her this relationship angle of our decision and she got quiet and looked at me for a second. She then said that she thinks if her own mom had made a similar decision things would have turned out differently for both of them during those years.

Now, who really knows what would have happened there (just like who knows how God is going to continue to grow and shape and change the six of us in our own family over the coming years), but I took that conversation as yet another confirmation in a long line of other little confirmations to us over the past couple of weeks that this was the next step we needed to take regarding the girls’ education.

Reason #4: We’ve been thinking for a long time that our girls would go to the school where Craig teaches once they reach that age (7th grade). Putting the girls in this particular elementary school at this particular time will hopefully do two things: 1) help them foster relationships with other kids who will be entering into the same school as 7th graders; and 2) possibly catch any gaps in their education they may have before heading into middle- and upper- school levels.

The second obvious question we’re being asked is, “Why Christian school?” The answer to that has several factors as well. We are not an anti-public school family. I know a lot of people who really believe they are called to put their kids into public schools and a lot of them do it for the purpose of meeting unbelievers. I will not downplay their decision to do that. We simply have different goals there, and while I’m not opposed to the idea of public school someday, it won’t be for the purpose of meeting unbelievers. If we choose that option some day it will be because we believe it to be in the best educational interests and spiritual development of our kids.

I believe in infusing our girls’ education with a Christian worldview. When conflict arises at school (and it will – where there are people there will be conflict, that’s the way it goes), I want someone walking the girls through that who can point the kids to Christ. I’m not as interested in them learning to be good citizens with each other as I am in them learning how to deal with each other in a God-honoring way (if they learn the latter, they will be the former).

Let’s face it: the tween years are hard enough. They are formative in a lot of ways and if I’m going to entrust my girls to someone else’s guidance for 7 hours a day, 5 days a week, I want that guidance to be with people who not only believe in Jesus themselves, but are free to have those conversations with kids without sneaking it into the conversation somehow.

So, that’s a very long way of letting everyone know that we really have turned into an “Education: Home & Otherwise” kind of family. Starting on August 19, we will enter the world of packed lunches and carpool lines. And I’m feeling really good about that decision.


14 thoughts on “Education: Home & Otherwise

  1. RT says:

    Kudos on the decision! You wrote your reasons so concisely—call me impressed. You are kind to share your reasons for sending your oldest girls to Christian school next year, even though you obviously don’t have to. I’m excited to read more about your entry into this new world!


  2. aubrey says:

    i know this was tough, but as someone who went to a christian school followed by public HS and junior high – there are great academic opportunities to be had all around. And I think I’ve heard you say (or seen you write??) that you have always wanted to make decisions about schooling for every girl every year.
    I’m also excited to see you share your experiences in the coming months.


  3. Monica says:

    I think your closing sentence captures the whole thing – how you are feeling about it. That says volumes. So glad God is showing you what is best for you and your family! I loved going to a Christian school BTW!


  4. Jolyn@Budgets are the New Black says:

    What a wonderful, transparent, introspective post. I can totally appreciate and comprehend all of the reasons behind your decision. It will be so interesting for you to look back on this post once you’ve had some time to adapt to the transition. I’d love to read about your thoughts then, too.
    I am still strongly considering starting to homeschool myself after we move from Ohio to California, but it looks like we’ll be moving later than we thought, so the kids will probably go ahead and complete another semester in public school starting in the fall. I admit, I’m relieved to have more time to prepare! I’m not as apprehensive about homeschooling my two younger ones, but I am still on the fence about my soon-to-be high schooler until I gain more confidence in how to go about it!
    Thanks for directing me to this post. I am very glad I got to read it. 🙂


  5. gretchen from lifenut says:

    I’ve been curious about your decision and really enjoyed this post.
    Welcome to the carpool line and packed lunches brigade! Make sure to bring something to read when you are waiting to retrieve your girls and don’t expect them to eat the entire sandwich.


  6. Jawan says:

    Thank you for being real. Some of the best advice I was ever given in regards to the education of my children was that “every year may look different for every child in your family”. What freedom!


  7. says:

    Megan: Wow! I know this decision was not made lightly. Your girls have a great foundation–both academically and as young women/people–I’m sure they will do great! Have a great summer!


  8. B. says:

    Great post, Megan. Thank you for sharing your decision with us. My kids have been (mostly) in Christian schools with a little homeschooling sprinkled in. But, my middle child is now in public high school. She’s being taught philosophies I didn’t expect her to hear until she went away to college. It’s been surprising. I am so thankful for the foundation she was given at a young age through Christian education that has taught her to recognize and think through the meaning of different worldviews.
    The Christian school my youngest is in (which is wonderful!) may not be able to continue with upper grades so we might eventually be looking at going back to a homeschooling/co-op situation. Gulp!
    What I desire the most for my children’s education is that they are given one that is founded on a Christian worldview which teaches them to think through things for themselves, to value excellence, and to “learn how to learn.” We’ve found that met well in a classical Christian environment…whether at home or in a classroom setting.
    Best wishes for you and yours. It’s an adventure, isn’t it? ~B.


  9. martha68 says:

    LOVED your article! my observation over the years of both myself and others has told me that so many people parent/educate for others. it is an easy trap to fall into. to be able to parent our children individually for THEIR needs and the goals of the family frequently takes not only courage but the need to eat some of our words. I have always loved how homeschooling for you was not a crusade, but something that met the needs of the family each year. One thing we found with our daughters was that as they were out with other families in school they realized that their family wasn’t so bad:) in fact, often was to be preferred. it was a nice side benefit.


  10. autumn says:

    Great post!! We did the same thing with our oldest. I wasn’t willing to sacrifice our relationship for homeschooling either. Thanks for being so honest!!
    I think I’m a better homeschool mom to fewer children. I always taught to the oldest and realized that my younger four weren’t getting taught much at all.


  11. Melanie:::Adorkable says:

    I really appreciate this post. My husband and I have talked about the education of our future family and we have very similar thoughts to you. We’ve both worked in the public school system and seen many reasons to homeschool–for at least the primary grades. I really like your reasoning for sending the older girls to a traditional classroom environment. Thanks for sharing!


  12. Jenny says:

    Great post! Sometimes I don’t feel like I do a good enough job homeschooling and that my daughter is missing out on something. I’m also in the St. Louis area. Would you mind telling me which school it is? I would be curious to know which one you all chose, because of your homeschool background.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s